Skip to main content

Beat

Waste and scandals

Where public money went wrong, who decided, and what the record says. Every entry links to the official finding.

The number

$110.3B

documented in overruns, failures and improper spending on this site, so far

Trans Mountain expansion: Kinder Morgan’s capital cost against the PBO’s total project costThe total project cost is now 6.3 times Kinder Morgan’s 2013 capital cost, the company’s own figure, not a price Ottawa paid, and at least 4.8 times after inflation. Red is the PBO’s total project cost.
  1. Kinder Morgan’s capital costDecember 2013 application$5.4B
  2. Total project costThe PBO’s latest estimate, 2024$34.2B
Kinder Morgan and the Parliamentary Budget Officer

ArriveCAN

$59.5M

The Auditor General’s estimate of what the app cost in all. The first version was built for $80,000. One firm, GC Strategies, accounted for $19.1M of the total.

Read the investigation

What the waste file counts

The number at the top adds up six documented overruns, failures and improper payments. Each is counted once, and only for its overrun, its failure cost or the payments to people and businesses that did not qualify, never a whole program. Loans repaid, private court orders and cancelled deals are not in it. The six items, and the full measure.

Ottawa also writes off, forgives and waives debts it is owed: from $4.3B in 2015-16 to $7.0B in 2024-25, with $18.5B in 2023-24, the year $10.2B of CEBA loans were forgiven. Write-offs, year by year.

Canadian Surface Combatant: the original budget against the latest estimateNow 3.2 times the 2008 budget, both in dollars of the years they are spent. The PBO’s 2022 report gives its estimate only in those dollars, so the multiple after inflation can’t be measured from it. Its 2017 report gave both: $39.9B in 2017 dollars against $61.8B as spent. Red is the PBO’s estimate to develop and build, not money spent yet.
  1. The original budget2008, in then-year dollars$26.2B
  2. The latest estimatePBO estimate, 2022$84.5B

The PBO’s estimate of the ships’ cost over their lives is larger again. The build contract, the yard money and the lobbying record.

The Parliamentary Budget Officer

Latest

Trans Mountain’s latest cost estimate: $34.2BCOVID benefits paid to people who didn’t qualify: $14BCost of fixing Phoenix’s pay errors: $5.1B
Forgiven or not expected back, by our count: $18BFederal spending on outside professional services, 2024-25: $19.6BFederal contracts awarded to McKinsey, 2011 to 2023: $209M

The standing pages

Added in one River-class amendment

$2.74B

Reported for January to March 2026. The disclosure gives no reason.

The PBO’s price for the fleet

$84.5B

To develop and build, 2022.

More on the beat

What changed

  • UpdateListed the full article on outside professional services.

  • UpdateThe documented waste total counts Phoenix at its documented minimum cost.

  • UpdateShorter sentences in the opening lines.

All changes
  • UpdateListed the full articles on Trans Mountain, Phoenix and the COVID benefits.

  • UpdateFixed the inflation multiples for Trans Mountain and the warships.

  • UpdateReworked the hub to lead with the pipeline’s first estimate.

  • UpdateThe label on the orange number band darkened to meet the contrast standard.

  • UpdateNamed the sources of the pipeline cost and chart figures.

  • UpdateRedesigned the hub with a lead chart and a chart for each feature.

  • PublishedOpened the waste beat hub.